Why background checks aren’t enough to prevent abuse in your church

March 12, 2021

I’m deeply saddened every time I read about accounts of abuse in the church, and I frequently see one statement from church leaders that makes me cringe: “We conducted a background check.”

Background checks are important, but they are only one small step in vetting prospective volunteers for serving in ministry. In fact, background checks are a low standard for protecting children and youth.

Few reported cases of child sexual abuse result in criminal convictions that place offenders on the National Sex Abuse Registry.

Child sex abuse cases are difficult to prosecute due to many factors, which include a lack of concrete evidence, a lack of trust in the veracity of victim’s testimony (especially young children) and the length of time between an assault and its disclosure. One study found that less than one in five reported cases of child sex abuse goes forward to prosecution, and only about half of those result in a conviction or guilty plea.

Background checks are important, but they are only one small step in vetting prospective volunteers for serving in ministry.

Beyond conducting background checks, what can your church do to increase protection of children and youth in your ministry setting?

  1. Have written policies in place and enforce them.
    Create written policies that outline the expectation for volunteers and staff in their interactions with children and youth. Include specificity about having at least two adults serving together so that no adult is ever alone with a child or youth. Have a mandated period of time that an individual must wait before being allowed to serve with children and youth in your ministry. The waiting period allows other adults to become more familiar with the person who wants to serve and can be a deterrent for those who want immediate access to children and youth. Include in your policy the steps for protecting minors at camp or other off-site ministries.
  2. Conduct a thorough screening of all volunteers.
    Vet all prospective volunteers before allowing them to serve. Have them complete an application to serve that includes written permission to conduct a criminal background check, along with contact references. Furthermore, schedule an in-person interview. Several resources to assist with these steps are available at ncbaptist.org/safety-and-security-nc.
  3. Train volunteers in sexual abuse recognition and prevention.
    Grooming a child or teen for sexual abuse often follows a set pattern of behavior by the abuser. Training leaders to look for these patterns is crucial to prevention. It’s also important to train volunteers about steps your church has taken to protect children and youth in your policies and what to do if grooming or abuse is suspected. More information on abuse prevention and the grooming process is available online through MinistrySafe at ministrysafe.com/ChildSafety. MinistrySafe is an organization that works with churches and ministries on abuse prevention.
  4. Understand and communicate reporting processes and procedures.
    Informing volunteers and parents about your church’s reporting system is important, as well as knowing your state’s mandatory reporting laws. In North Carolina, if abuse is suspected, there is a legal mandate to report it to your county’s Child Protective Services. Reports made to church staff or designated church representatives do not remove the requirement to report to Child Protective Services by the person who suspects abuse.
  5. Conduct a review of your facility.
    Take a hard look at your facility, and identify any possible areas where abuse could occur. Be sure every meeting space in the church has a window in or near the door to allow a clear sightline into the space. Minimize and limit access to hidden corners and storage areas where a child or teen could be abused.
  6. Watch for potential abuse between children.
    A high percentage of reported abuse occurs between minors. Have sufficient numbers of volunteers to monitor relationships between children and youth. Look for children or youth who use an imbalance of power to intimidate, threaten, bully or abuse others.

Implementing these steps will help you and your church develop a comprehensive plan to prevent abuse. Background checks should be a part of that plan, but not the only part. For additional resources and information about preventing sexual abuse in your ministry context, visit the Baptist State Convention of North Carolina’s resource page at ncbaptist.org/safety-and-security-nc or contact childhood ministry consultant, Cheryl Markland, at [email protected].

by Cheryl Markland  
/  Childhood Evangelism and Discipleship  /  Baptist State Convention of North Carolina

Board affirms Unzicker as EDT nominee

Todd Unzicker, chief of staff at The Summit Church in Raleigh-Durham, has been nominated by the Baptist State Convention of North Carolina’s (BSCNC) board of directors to become the next executive director-treasurer of the state convention. The board voted to approve Unzicker’s...

4 kinds of pastors whose churches need revitalizing

Revitalization is one of those things pastors Google when no one else is looking. As I travel across the state, I meet pastors who minister in a variety of contexts — rural, urban, small, large, plants and even replants. Some of these pastors know their church is in need of...

5 ways pastors should respond to setbacks in ministry

Things don’t always turn out the way we desire. Oftentimes, we find ourselves asking questions about why something happened, or why we didn’t see it coming. We wonder why God allowed it or have difficulty seeing how God’s plan is being accomplished through it. Phrases such as...

How families can adopt a family discipleship plan

Many parents have made 2021 the year of discipleship for their family. They have taken the challenge and implemented the “Family Discipleship Plan” in their homes. Moms and dads have made this a priority because they know they have been given the wonderful privilege of being the...

Why leading your child to Christ is a process, not just a prayer

I remember praying a prayer at age 5. As a Cubby in the Awana program at our church, I was slightly intimidated by the leader who took me into the darkened chapel and asked me if I wanted to go to heaven to be with Jesus. I didn’t know what that meant. I may have asked a few...

3 steps to being missional in your community

The COVID-19 pandemic, along with heightened racial and political tensions, have sparked massive conflicts throughout our state and nation in the last year and a half. However, in the midst of the chaos, families have a unique opportunity to be missional in their homes and...

God’s presence provides comfort in times of transition

“It isn’t the changes that do you in, it’s the transitions!” These words by the late William Bridges, who was a leading authority on organizational leadership, have been ringing in my mind throughout the last year. When our country went into lockdown due to the pandemic, it was an...

Students: An untapped resource for serving in your church

I’ve heard it said that students are the church of tomorrow, but I really struggle with that — I believe students are the church of today and the future church leaders of tomorrow. Students need adults who love Jesus, love them and take the time to disciple them. They need...

View this webinar to learn more about creating safe and secure environments for your ministries.

Email [email protected] or call (800) 395-5102, ext. 5646 for more information.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get the latest news and event information by signing up for the Childhood Ministry newsletter.

Select Language ^

Share This

Share this with your friends!