Regathering & the First Amendment: Celebrating freedom, exercising wisdom

May 18, 2020

On Saturday, a federal judge issued a temporary restraining order, effectively lifting the restrictions on indoor religious services as outlined in N.C. Gov. Roy Cooper’s executive order No. 138.

In his ruling, U.S. District Court Judge James C. Dever III of the Eastern District of North Carolina noted, “There is no pandemic exception to the Constitution of the United States or the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment.”

A spokesman for Cooper said in a statement that the governor will not appeal the federal court’s ruling, but encouraged church leaders to take precautions to keep members safe.

What should churches do in light of the court’s order? Does this mean that churches should regather? This is a time for the people of God to celebrate freedom and exercise wisdom. As parents often tell their children, “just because you can do it doesn’t mean you should do it.”

As American citizens, Christians can celebrate the protection of the rights granted under the Constitution to freely exercise religion and peaceably assemble. At the same time, as citizens of a greater kingdom (Colossians 1:13), Christians can exercise judgment to make the wisest decision possible for the sake of their own church family and neighbors.

John Stonestreet, president of the Colson Center for Christian Worldview, frequently notes that Christians need to learn to walk and chew gum at the same time. Simply put, we must learn to do two things at once. This idea applies to the current decision to hold an indoor worship service.

As Christians blessed to live in a nation with religious protections in the Constitution, believers should steward well those rights and indeed contend for them. Such a stance can and should be done in accordance with Romans 13:1-2.

Thankfully, American Christians are afforded legal levers that can be engaged to rightfully and respectfully disagree with governing authorities, such as appealing a state ruling in federal court. So, speaking up to secure freedom under the law is a good and necessary practice. Yet believers should also exercise sound judgment under the counsel of the Word and the Holy Spirit to make wise decisions.

One could argue that confidence in people exercising such common sense is one of the characteristics necessary for a constitutional republic to survive. In this case, the church has the advantage of the federal laws that protect the right to gather. But if we apply the principles of 1 Corinthians 10:23-33, gathering should be more an issue of conscience in glorifying God and loving our neighbor.

Scripture would demand of believers to not just do what is lawful but what builds up; not just to seek their own good but the good of their neighbor (1 Corinthians 10:23-24). The passage ends by pointing out that the exercise of freedom should be tempered with a sensitivity to glorify God and be a witness to our neighbors: “So, whether you eat or drink, or whatever you do (including gathering), do all for the glory of God. Give no offense to Jews or to Greeks or to the church of God, just as I try to please everyone in everything I do, not seeking my own advantage, but that of many, that they may be saved” (1 Corinthians 10:31-3).

Churches should not rush to reopen just because a federal judge says they have the right. Nor should churches reopen just because our state has reached a particular phase in a reopening plan. Rather, the church should ask God for wisdom and make the best decision they can through prayer, study of the Word and the counsel of other believers.

So, should we regather or not? That is a matter of conscience for each local, autonomous church to decide. Each church has the freedom in Christ and the burden of responsibility to make the best decision in a time when there are no easy decisions. With that in mind here are some things the church can do:

1. Thank God that we live in a nation where the freedom to assemble is protected by the Constitution. We also should pray for our brothers and sisters throughout the world who do not share in this liberty.

2. Ask God for wisdom to do what is best for your local congregation.

3. Consider the elderly and the vulnerable who may feel torn between attending out of obligation and their own personal health if the church doors are open.

4. Consider which option is the best witness to the watching unbeliever.

5. Consult local health officials for guidance on safety and hygiene.

6. Consider whether your facility can accommodate a worship gathering while taking the proper precautions.

7. Whenever you plan to regather, make a plan and communicate it as much and as early as possible to your church.

8. Be gracious to Christians who have a different viewpoint than you do, and respect your church leaders as they make the decisions they deem best.

Above all, please do not see the choice about what to do on Sunday as an issue of “reopening.” The church has never closed! A biblical understanding of the church acknowledges that the church is the people, not the steeple.

For those who recognize their mission, the church has been wide open during this pandemic. They have been alive and actively carrying out acts of love and service to the community, innovating and imagining new ways to minister the gospel to one another and their neighbors.

We should long to gather again, and we will rejoice when we can. Today, let’s pray for pastors, elders, deacons and other leaders to have wisdom and discernment to do whatever they do to the glory of God!


by Brian Upshaw  
/  Disciple-Making Team  /  Baptist State Convention of North Carolina

Baptist Children’s Homes breaks ground for three new foster care homes

Almost 300 staff members and trustees of the Baptist Children’s Homes of North Carolina (BCH), Cleveland County dignitaries, supporters and friends came together on Sept. 11 for the groundbreaking of three new homes near Shelby, N.C. River Hill Refuge, as it will be known, will...

10 principles for leading in church revitalization

Many churches in our world today are in deep need of revitalization. In order to lead your church in revitalization, there are some basic principles you must follow. Here are 10 principles for a revitalizer: Be humble. You must swallow your pride, humble yourself and love even...

What you can do when your church is in decline

Facing reality in churches can be tough. When a faithful, dedicated church member of many years sees the church losing ground as the neighborhood around the congregation changes, painful feelings emerge and uncertainty abounds. This feeling is exacerbated when one’s age puts them...

5 reasons you should care about the new church fostering movement

A new movement is emerging among churches of all sizes. Though in its infancy, this movement has the potential to add a significant amount of energy to the world of church revitalization. The church fostering movement is one you should follow. What is church fostering? It’s good...

Help and Hope: ‘Humanity at its finest’

The remnants of Tropical Storm Fred dumped unexpected levels of rain on western North Carolina last month, pushing the Pigeon River beyond its banks in Haywood County and causing devastation to homes in its path. Aug. 17, 2021, is a date many residents will never forget. “I have...

Baptism Sunday requires volunteer training, preparation, pastor says

As part of Baptism Sunday alongside other Southern Baptists, Mercy Church has several names slated of those to enter the baptistry Sept. 12. But it’s those unplanned baptisms, said Pastor Spence Shelton, that require an extra level of training for volunteers. Of course, anyone who...

20 years later: Baptists on Mission remember 9/11 response

When the National 9/11 Pentagon Memorial was closed to the public this summer because of COVID-19 restrictions, Skip Greene drove as close as he could to the gate. Greene, a longtime member of First Baptist Church of Boone, wanted to see the place where he served 20 years ago,...

Tharrington honored for 50 years of service with Baptists on Mission

Lynn Tharrington had two dreams as a little girl — to work in an office and serve as a missionary. Never in her wildest imagination did Tharrington think she would get to do both for 50 years while serving North Carolina Baptists in the same role for the entirety of her working...

4 Comments

  1. Dr. Shirley Lynn

    Everything you say is good but the church is a source of love, health, care, the church is the people but the Bible which you did not quote is “We are not to forsake the assembling of ourselves and some have done.”
    The Disciples did not close down when there were trouble many died for their belief. We are Christians and the Church is where we gather to worship and the Church should be open.
    If someone feels unsure about God care then stay home but the Church needs to be open.
    Also I saw nothing the Southern Baptist was doing in this time of need. I have much more to say but I will limit it at this time.

    Reply
  2. James Harrington

    Great Article Brian. Such thoughtful insight and very helpful to me in the decision process of what’s next.
    Thank you so much.
    God Bless!

    Reply
  3. Wayne Harris

    You said it well. Thank you!

    Reply
  4. Mary Anne Goslen

    This is an excellent article. My husband and I are in our mid-80s, and we are considered at-risk because of our health. We worship on Sundays by tuning in to TV programs that have ministers who give good biblical messages. We spend an hour discussing what we have heard. We still give our tithes each month to our church and often hear from a church member. For years we were faithful to not only attend church regularly but also serve in different capacities. We are not attending now because the virus could easily attack us in a crowded situation. Several years ago I caught the flu from someone at church, and I almost died. Now I have to be very careful.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay connected by signing up for the N.C. Baptist monthly newsletter.

Select Language ^

Share This

Share this with your friends!